Our flavors.
Part of making ice cream by hand is the joy of changing things up frequently. That means these flavors might be the flavors of the day or they might have changed. Check our socials for any changes or updates in flavors:
instagram/threads: @thirdtimeicecreamco, bluesky: @thirdtimeicecream.bsky.social, twitter: @thirdtimeic
Basic Pricing
$5.50
Small Cup
Two half scoops of ice cream
$5.50
$7.00
Medium Cup
Three half scoops of ice cream
$7.00
$8.50
Large Cup
Four half scoops of ice cream
$8.50
$0
Wafer Cones
Your childhood favorite
$0
$12.50
In Shop Pints
$12.50
This Month's Flavors: President's Day and a Love Letter
Amchoor Hour (vegan)
beware the orange menace | amchoor (dried green mango) ice cream with persimmon-rose jam and quick-pickled mango
Freckled Red Chili Tea
echoes of a date at the biscuit | a custard with MEM's red chili tea latte speckled with cacao, ancho chili, vanilla, and cinnamon
Secret Password
wait, that's why they say, "open sesame?" | ultra-rich chocolate ice cream with a nutty hit of roasted sesame
(Not?) Gonna Do It
honoring dana carvey's bush | inspired by gianduja, a chocolate gelato with our house praline made of hazelnut, almond, and a touch of coconut
On a Date (vegan)
not to date myself... | coconut and jasmine rice ice cream with date + tamarind and blueberry-coriander ribbons
Coffee and Dessert
the perfect after-dinner denouement | broadsheet coffee custard swirled with banana, clove, and cinnamon
Something Pink
a little pink gelato for saint valentine | raspberry gelato with swirls of our sweetened condensed milk perfumed with smoked star anise
Impassioned Chocolate
memories of passion fruits growing wild | chocolate ice cream cut with passion fruit caramel and reverse stracciatella of passion fruit-infused white chocolate