Our flavors.
Part of making ice cream by hand is the joy of changing things up frequently. That means these flavors might be the flavors of the day or they might have changed. Check our socials for any changes or updates in flavors:
instagram: @thirdtimeicecreamco, threads: @thirdtimeicecreamco, twitter: @thirdtimeic, bluesky: @thirdtimeicecream.bsky.social
Basic Pricing
$5.50
Small Cup
Two half scoops of ice cream
$5.50
$7.00
Medium Cup
Three half scoops of ice cream
$7.00
$8.50
Large Cup
Four half scoops of ice cream
$8.50
$0
Wafer Cones
Your childhood favorite
$0
$2
Waffle Cones
Made in house
$2
Spicy (+$1)
This Month's Flavors: Thanksgiving Food and Drink
A Bit of Sage Advice
here it is: eat your veggies | honeynut squash ice with sage and brown butter
The Salad Course
start your meal off right | grapefruit-buttermilk sherbet with fennel marmalade and a splash of fennel frond creme
The Sauced Cranberry (vegan)
get sauced | cranberry-mulled wine sorbet
FML (the Fenugreek/Maple Latte)
what else would it stand for? | a post-election-seasonally-appropriate broadsheet coffee and fenugreek custard with pockets of smoked salt and maple-y squash
Salted & Malted (Chocolate)
nestle eat your heart out | chocolate gelato swirled with malted and hopped caramel and crunchy rice krispies
Use Your Noggin
a twist on the creamy holiday favorite | egg nog custard with a touch of nutmeg and mahlab caramel
A Foggy Day (vegan)
earl who? | coconut ice cream with floral & sour bergamot oranges and tahitian vanilla
The Perfect (Pear)ing
what are friends for? | a smooth gelato of chestnuts and pears
Special Waffle Cones
$3
Spicy Waffle Cones
$3